This is a revised version of a question I already posted, but which patently was ill posed. Please give me another try.
For comparison's sake, the axioms of a metric:
Axiom A1: $(forall x) d(x,x) = 0$
Axiom A2: $(forall x,y) d(x,y) = 0 rightarrow x = y$
Axiom A3: $(forall x,y) d(x,y) = d(y,x)$
Axiom A4: $(forall x,y,z) d(x,y) + d(y,z) geq d(x,z)$
Let $T$ = {X,T} be a topology, $B$ a base of $T$, $x, y, z$ $in$ X
Definition D0: $x$ is nearer to $y$ than to $z$ with respect to $B$ ($N_Bxyz$) iff $(exists b in B) x, y in b & z notin b & (nexists b in B) x, z in b & y notin b$
Definition D1: $B$ is pre-metric1 iff $(forall x,y) x neq y rightarrow N_Bxxy$
Definition D2: $B$ is pre-metric2 iff $(forall x,y,z) ((z neq x & z neq y) rightarrow N_Bxyz) rightarrow x = y$
Definition D3: $B$ is pre-metric3 iff $(forall x,y,z) N_Bzyx rightarrow (N_Byxz rightarrow N_Bxyz)$
Definition: $T$ is pre-metrici iff $(exists B) B$ is pre-metrici (i = 1,2,3).
Definition: $B$ is pre-metric iff $B$ is pre-metric1, pre-metric2 and pre-metric3.
Definition: $T$ is pre-metric iff $(exists B) B$ is pre-metric.
Remark: D1 is an analogue of axiom A1, D2 of axiom A2, D3 of axiom A3.
Remark: $T$ is pre-metric1 iff $T$ is T1[not quite sure].
Remark: If $T$ is induced by a metric, then $T$ is pre-metric.
Question: Can a property pre-metric4 be defined such that $T$ induces a metric iff $T$ is induced by a metric with
Definition: $B$ is metric iff $B$ is pre-metric and pre-metric4.
Definition: $T$ induces a metric iff $(exists B) B$ is metric.
Remark: Property pre-metric4 should be an analogue of A4 (the triangle inequality).
If provably no such property can be defined does this shed a light on the difference (an asymmetry) between topologies and metric spaces? ("It's the triangle inequality, that cannot be captured topologically.")
No comments:
Post a Comment